Neuroscience of why bad things happen to good people – brain with neural pathways, RAS, DMN and trauma wiring

The Neuroscience of Why Bad Things Happen to Good People: How Your Brain Learns, Predicts, and Repeats Your Reality

We’ve all heard the phrase, “Bad things always happen to good people.” Maybe you’ve lived it:

You show up for everyone, but people don’t show up for you.
You put others first, yet you’re the one who gets taken advantage of.
You work hard, but the same stressful patterns repeat in relationships, family, or work.

It can feel like life is unfair or that you’re somehow cursed. But beneath the heartbreak and frustration, there’s something profoundly practical going on: your brain is doing exactly what it was wired to do.

In this article, we’ll explore the neuroscience behind this feeling using four key systems:

RAS – Reticular Activating System: your brain’s attention filter
DMN – Default Mode Network: your internal narrative and self-story
Trauma wiring: how past experiences shape what feels “normal”
Predictive processing: how your brain keeps recreating familiar patterns

Most importantly, we’ll talk about what you can do to teach your brain something new so that “good person” no longer equals “constant self-sacrifice and pain.”

1. “Good people” are often trained to abandon themselves

Many of us were raised with explicit or subtle rules like:

“Don’t be selfish.”
“Be nice. Don’t make others uncomfortable.”
“Keep the peace, even if it hurts you.”

Over time, this doesn’t just become a belief. It becomes a neural habit. Every time you:

say yes when you mean no,
ignore your body’s signals,
stay quiet instead of setting a boundary,

you’re teaching your brain: “My needs are not important. Other people come first.”

Your nervous system doesn’t see this as “kindness.” It treats it as survival strategy. Keeping others happy becomes wired as the safest option – which means your brain will keep steering you toward situations where you repeat the same pattern.

To understand why this keeps happening, we need to look at how the brain filters reality.

2. The RAS: your brain’s attention bouncer

The Reticular Activating System (RAS) is a network of nuclei in the brainstem involved in regulating wakefulness, arousal, and which incoming sensory signals reach your conscious awareness. Think of it as the bouncer at the door of your attention.

At any moment, your senses are flooded with far more information than you can consciously process. The RAS helps decide:

What you notice
What you ignore
What feels urgent or important enough to respond to

Contrary to popular self-help myths, the Reticular Activating System is not a magical “manifestation” switch. It doesn’t read your goals or values. But it is strongly influenced by:

what you repeatedly focus on,
what you associate with safety or danger,
and what your past has taught you to expect.

How self-abandonment programs your RAS

If your life history has taught you that:

“Other people’s moods are more important than mine,” or
“It’s dangerous to upset people,”

then your Reticular Activating System becomes finely tuned to:

notice tension in others,
scan for disapproval,
pick up tiny shifts in tone or facial expression,
overlook your own exhaustion, resentment, or body signals.

That means you’ll naturally:

spot the one person in the room who needs rescuing,
be drawn to emotionally hungry or chaotic people,
miss the signs of genuine reciprocity and respect.

It can feel like “bad people” always find you. In reality, your brain’s filter has been trained to highlight them while dimming everything else.

3. The DMN: your brain’s self-story and “meaning maker”

The Default Mode Network (DMN) is a large-scale brain network that becomes active when your mind is at rest, daydreaming, or turning inward. It supports:

self-reflection and self-referential thinking,
autobiographical memory (your personal life story),
imagining the future,
thinking about others and social situations.

You can think of the Default Mode Network as your brain’s inner narrator. It constantly answers questions like:

“Who am I?”
“What kind of things happen to me?”
“What do people expect from me?”

When your self-story is “I’m the one who holds everything together”

If you grew up in chaos, emotional neglect, or unpredictability, you may have unconsciously formed narratives like:

“I’m the strong one.”
“I don’t need much.”
“My job is to keep the peace / fix things / be the good one.”

Trauma and early-life stress can disrupt normal DMN development and alter how you see yourself, how you relate to others, and how you imagine your future. In simple language: trauma can literally reshape the way your brain tells your life story and imagines what’s possible.

So when “bad things” happen (someone uses you, betrays you, or dumps their emotional load on you), your Default Mode Network often weaves it into an old story:

“Of course this happened. This is just my life.”
“That’s what I get for expecting more.”
“If I had tried harder, they wouldn’t have left.”

The more often that narrative is repeated, the more it becomes your brain’s default script—and the harder it is to imagine a different reality.

4. Trauma wiring: when your nervous system normalizes danger

Trauma isn’t just about catastrophic events. It includes chronic emotional stress—like walking on eggshells around a parent, being shamed for your needs, or always being the “responsible one” in a family that leans on you.

Overwhelming experiences reshape brain regions involved in threat detection, emotion regulation, and self-awareness. Over time, your body and brain adapt by:

staying on high alert for danger,
numbing or disconnecting from your own feelings,
repeating familiar (even painful) relational patterns because they feel safer than the unknown.

Why “good people” often end up with takers, abusers, or narcissists

If your nervous system learned early on that:

love means over-functioning,
connection means taking care of others,
conflict means danger,

then your body will often feel strangely calm or magnetized around people who:

take more than they give,
expect you to manage their emotions,
benefit from your lack of boundaries.

Not because you’re weak, naïve, or broken—but because your nervous system has wired this pattern as “how relationships work.”

5. Predictive processing: your brain is constantly guessing what comes next

Modern neuroscience increasingly sees the brain as a prediction machine. Instead of passively reacting to the world, it constantly uses past experience to guess what will happen next and what incoming signals mean. This is often called predictive processing or active inference.

Your brain constantly:

compares incoming sensory input to its predictions,
feels “right” and uses less energy when reality matches those predictions,
and has to work harder—and feel less safe—when reality doesn’t match what it expects.

Psychologist Lisa Feldman Barrett describes how the brain uses prediction, past experience, and context to generate emotions and meaning—not just raw reactions to the present moment. In other words, your feelings are deeply tied to what your brain expects to happen next.

How this keeps you stuck in painful patterns

If your history has taught your brain:

“I am the one who tries harder,”
“People leave / disappoint / use me,”
“My needs come last,”

then your predictive brain quietly expects:

partners who are emotionally unavailable,
workplaces that exploit your work ethic,
friendships where you’re the unpaid therapist.

When you meet someone healthy—who respects your boundaries, cares about your needs, and doesn’t demand self-abandonment—your brain may register this as:

“boring,”
“too much,”
“not a spark,”
or even “unsafe” (because it violates your prediction).

Meanwhile, someone who fits your old pattern will feel strangely familiar, intense, or “meant to be,” even if they’re not actually good for you. That’s predictive processing at work.

6. Why it feels like “bad things only happen to good people”

When you combine all of these systems, a powerful loop emerges:

Early environment and trauma teach you that your safety depends on pleasing, fixing, or shrinking yourself.
Your Reticular Activating System starts prioritizing cues that match that survival strategy (people who need saving, signs of disapproval, etc.).
Your Default Mode Network builds a self-story around being the strong one, the caretaker, the “good person who can handle it.”
Predictive processing uses that story to choose what feels normal, pulling you toward familiar dynamics—even when they hurt.

From the inside, it looks like:

“Why do I always attract toxic people?”
“Why does life keep punching me in the face when I’m trying so hard to be good?”

From the brain’s perspective, it’s simpler: “I am repeating what I learned, because familiar equals safe.”

The hopeful part? Anything that was wired can be rewired. It’s not instant, and it’s not about “thinking positive.” It’s about steadily teaching your nervous system, your attention filters, and your predictive brain a different reality.

7. How to start teaching your brain that you matter

Here are practical, neuroscience-informed ways to begin shifting the pattern. You don’t have to do all of them at once. Think of them as small “experiments” to gently update your brain’s predictions.

Step 1: Notice your body before you fix the situation

Your body is often aware of danger or self-abandonment before your thoughts catch up. Start building a habit of pausing and asking:

“What am I feeling in my body right now?”
“Am I tightening, shrinking, or holding my breath?”
“Do I feel pulled to fix, appease, or over-explain?”

Even 10–20 seconds of noticing before you answer a text, say yes, or jump in to help creates a micro-gap in the prediction loop. That gap is where new choices become possible.

Step 2: Tiny boundaries that contradict the old script

Your predictive brain won’t believe new data until it sees it repeatedly and safely. Instead of dramatic boundary overhauls, start with small, survivable experiments like:

Taking an hour before responding to a non-urgent message.
Politely declining a request you genuinely don’t have capacity for.
Leaving a draining conversation 5 minutes earlier than usual.

Each time you set a tiny boundary and survive the discomfort, your brain updates: “Maybe I can say no and still be safe. Maybe I do matter.” This directly challenges your old predictions.

Step 3: Rewrite your DMN narrative (on paper)

Because the Default Mode Network is deeply involved in self-story and autobiographical memory, journaling can be a powerful way to gently edit your script. Try prompts like:

“Growing up, what did I learn about my role in the family?”
“What did I have to do to feel safe or loved?”
“What would a kinder, updated version of that story sound like?”

You’re not erasing your past. You’re adding new, more complete chapters that include your needs, anger, grief, and desires—not just your usefulness to others.

Step 4: Train your RAS to notice safety and reciprocity

Since the Reticular Activating System is influenced by what you repeatedly focus on, you can start consciously directing it to notice different cues:

Who actually checks in on you without needing something?
Where do you feel a sense of ease or being “allowed to exist” as you are?
Which micro-moments of respect, kindness, or support show up in your day?

You’re not ignoring red flags—you’ve already been wired to spot those. You’re building the counter-skill of seeing green flags, so your brain can recognize safe people and situations as real options.

Step 5: Seek support that understands trauma, not just “positivity”

Because trauma reshapes brain networks like the Default Mode Network and alters stress and inflammation pathways, support that understands these realities tends to be more effective than simple “think positive” advice. Modalities that may help include:

Trauma-informed psychotherapy (e.g., EMDR, IFS, somatic therapies).
Group work or support communities for people-pleasers, adult children of alcoholics, or family scapegoats.
Mindfulness or body-based practices that train you to stay present in your body rather than dissociating.

The goal isn’t to become “less good.” It’s to be good to yourself at the same level you’ve always been good to everyone else.

8. Growth mindset: from “Why me?” to “What is my brain trying to protect?”

A growth mindset doesn’t mean pretending everything is fine. It means shifting from:

“Bad things happen to me because I’m flawed or unlucky” to
“My brain is repeating what it learned. I can gently teach it something new.”

When you catch yourself in a familiar painful pattern, try asking:

“What prediction is my brain making right now?”
“What old story is being activated?”
“What is the smallest, kindest action I can take that honors me and gently contradicts that story?”

You are not weak for ending up in these situations. In a very real way, you are highly adaptive. Your brain has been working overtime for years to keep you safe in the only way it knew how.

Now you’re learning a different way—one that doesn’t require you to suffer for your goodness.

9. Putting it all together

“Bad things happening to good people” is not a cosmic joke or a moral verdict. It’s often the result of:

a brainstem filter (Reticular Activating System) tuned to other people’s needs,
a self-story (Default Mode Network) built around being the fixer or peacekeeper,
trauma wiring that equates familiarity with safety,
a predictive brain that keeps choosing what it already knows.

The work ahead isn’t about becoming less kind, less generous, or less loving. It’s about:

bringing that same compassion toward yourself,
updating the stories your brain tells about who you are,
and practicing small, consistent acts that prove to your nervous system that you also deserve care, respect, and safety.

Your brain has been listening to your behavior for years. Starting today, you can begin sending it a new message: “I am good—and I matter too.”

References

Arguinchona JH, et al. “Neuroanatomy, Reticular Activating System.” StatPearls, 2023.
“Reticular Activating System – an overview.” ScienceDirect Topics.
O’Brien I. “Let’s Talk About the RAS (and What Coaches Often Get Wrong).” 2025.
Uddin LQ, et al. “Towards a Universal Taxonomy of Macro-scale Functional Human Brain Networks.” Brain Topography, 2019.
Azarias FR, et al. “The Journey of the Default Mode Network: Development, Functions, and Clinical Significance.” Biology, 2025.
Poerio GL, et al. “The default mode network and the complex dynamics of self-generated thought.” 2025.
Daniels JK, et al. “Default mode alterations in posttraumatic stress disorder.” PNAS, 2011.
King S, et al. “Early life stress, low-grade systemic inflammation and altered DMN connectivity.” Translational Psychiatry, 2023.
van der Kolk B. The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma. 2014.
Hutchinson JB, Barrett LF. “The Power of Predictions: An Emerging Paradigm for Psychological Research.” Current Directions in Psychological Science, 2019.
Barrett LF. “The Predictive Brain and the ‘Hard Problem’ of Consciousness.” Psychology Today, 2023; and “The ‘Fight or Flight’ Idea Misses the Beauty of What the Brain Really Does.” Scientific American, 2024.

Search This Blog